What Happened to NFL Parity? Good, Bad Teams Farther Apart Than Ever
There are more 7-win teams this year than ever. And half the NFL is under .500.
Parity in the NFL is something the league has relied upon for years.
Every team has a legitimate chance of winning the Super Bowl at the beginning of every year.
Well, more or less.
And because teams are so evenly matched, we have upsets as well as close divisional and playoff races that come down to the final weeks of the season.
But this season the good and bad teams — the contenders and pretenders, if you will — are farther apart than ever.
What Happened to NFL Parity?
This year, the AFC playoff race is all but locked in. And we just finished up Week 10 of the season.
Like a kick wide right, that's no good.
Currently, the top five teams in the AFC — Buffalo, Kansas City, Cincinnati, Jacksonville, and Denver — have a 97% or better chance to make the playoffs per the NFL Playoff Picture.
The last two spots are occupied by Pittsburgh (73%) and Cleveland (47%) with only New England (45%) really being "in the hunt." CBS has Pittsburgh at 86% and Cleveland at 69%, further illustrating how locked in the AFC is.
The NFC is a little tighter, but there are still four teams with an 82% or better chance of making the postseason and realistically only 10 teams have a chance to fill all seven spots.
We're not even to Thanksgiving yet and 14 teams are all but eliminated. Some of them are actively tanking.
There's still almost half a season to play!
This isn't ideal for the sport on the whole. It hurts interest in the sport, ratings, and competitiveness.
The league is taking notice: The Panthers at 4-5 are the No. 4 seed in the NFC currently with three teams below them with better records. The same Panthers went 8-9 last year and were in that No. 4 spot. That's brought back up discussions about playoff seeding.
League officials are reportedly revisiting a discussion from the 2025 offseason about whether division winners with losing records should still receive a home playoff game and a top-four seed, per Graziano.
— NFL NEWS (@insidenflnews.bsky.social) 2026-11-18T15:24:43.230Z
Parity is Great for Surprises
Parity means every team has a chance at a Super Bowl. And that champions regularly change from year to year.
Still, there are always a few awful teams we know will be abominable in the preseason — Tennessee, Arizona, NY Jets, Miami this year.
Then again, there are also usually a whole host of surprise teams. And that has been true to a point this season. Albeit fewer than usual.
Cleveland is still hanging in the playoff picture at 6-4. Few predicted that. And the Giants leading the sorry NFC East is a bit of a surprise, even if that division is down in the dumps.
Surprises going the other way include the 1-8 Chargers falling off the face of the planet, the Texans plummeting to 3-6, and the Rams — everyone's preseason favorite to win the Super Bowl — currently on the outside looking in at 6-4. And the Ravens have face-planted since Lamar Jackson's injury.
For the most part, the contenders are who we thought they were at the beginning of the season. The Bills, Chiefs, Broncos, Niners, Seahawks, Lions, Bengals, with a few others mixed in.
Tanking is Bad for the Sport
Meanwhile, there are many teams actively tanking.
The Indianapolis Colts are the biggest example. They had a fire sale of players to build up draft picks in the future. DeForest Buckner went back to the 49ers and Quinton Nelson was traded to Seattle. Both players have a chance at a Super Bowl now, while the Colts have become an easy win for any team who plays them. Indy also traded away receiver Josh Downs to the Chiefs, and he caught on in his first week there last Sunday.
The Miami Dolphins, who had to sign cut day players from other teams as the season kicked off, are another example.
The Tennessee Titans traded away Jeffery Simmons as part of their tank.
And the Eagles, who have lost seven straight games are another example, though losing Jalen Hurts sank them.
In fact, there are currently 16 teams under .500. That's half the league!
The brilliance of the NFL most years is teams can still make a run down the stretch. Not this year for half the league.
More Top Teams and More Tanking Teams
The flip side of half of the league being out of the playoff race is we have more teams at 7-2 or higher than at any point in NFL history after 10 weeks.
Is NFL parity still a thing? I'm writing a column on it for The Broncos Blitz.
— Rich (@sportsballz.bsky.social) 2026-11-17T15:47:45.043Z
The cream has risen to the top, as Randy "Macho Man" Savage said back in the day.
Nine teams have 7 wins or more. Meanwhile, 12 teams have three wins or fewer.
Here’s how the standings have looked in recent years:
2025: 7 teams with 7-plus wins, 12 with 3 or fewer
2024: 8 and 11
2023: 4 and 7
2022: 4 and 11
The trend we're seeing over the last five years are a higher concentration of top-tier teams as well as more terrible teams.
Simply, the separation of the good teams vs. the bad ones makes for less interesting football, less exciting matchups, and a worse product down the stretch.
This week, there are currently five games that have double-digit spreads out of 13 total contests. That's nearly 40%.
Two of those games have the highest point spread of the season with 16.5-point favorites: The Bills vs. the Dolphins and the Chiefs vs. the Cardinals.
Two contenders vs. two tankers.
The irony is the NFL salary cap is supposed to keep teams within competitive range of one another. That's not happening, at least not this year.
The other irony is the NFL already expanded the season from 16 to 17 games, and they'll move from 17 to 18 soon.
We're going to see more lopsided games this year as the season goes on, making late-season football as unwatchable as the early-season games which have taken over for the preseason.
And as the league expands in games played, we'll likely see even less parity going forward. Teams know if they're out of it they can tank for their best possible draft position.
While the NBA has moved to try to mimic the NFL's parity — with eight different champions the last eight years — the NFL is moving away from parity. At least during their short regular season, in which every game counts.
Of course, the NBA has it's own problems with the season being too long. They've included the NBA Cup early in the season to keep casual fans interested and they hope the players will give more if they're chasing a piece of hardware.
And the NBA has seen tanking for years, which is why they instituted the Draft lottery.
While the NBA mimicked the NFL with a harder salary cap and it's resulted in parity, the NFL should consider a lottery of their own as teams tank in broad daylight.
Thanks for reading! Please subscribe today. Or leave a tip in the tip jar!
New offer: Get a free artwork print of your choice with a paid subscription.
Follow The Broncos Blitz on Bluesky!
Rich Kurtzman was born and raised in Denver Colorado and attended Colorado State University in Fort Collins in the aughts. He's been a professional writer since 2011, covering Colorado State football and men's basketball, as well as the Denver Broncos, for many outlets. Current Denver Broncos work can be found on Mile High Sports. Previous credits include CBS Denver and The USA TODAY Sports Media Group.
Comments ()